Explore more blog posts

TLL vs. Renters Insurance: Which Is Right for You?

By
Foxen Staff
March 26, 2025
Property Management
Renters Insurance
Renters Insurance Compliance

As a property owner, protecting your investment is a top priority. While lease agreements outline key responsibilities such as rent payments, lease length, and fair housing laws, they often do little to shield you from financial losses caused by resident negligence. That’s why it is crucial to ensure you and your residents have the right coverage in place to mitigate risk and safeguard your property.

Accidents happen—whether it’s a kitchen fire, an overflowing bathtub, or smoke damage from a candle left burning too long—, unexpected damages can lead to costly repairs. Requiring your renters to enroll in a tenant legal liability waiver (TLL waiver) program or purchase a renters insurance (HO4) policy, helps ensure that both you and your residents are financially protected when these incidents occur.

TLL waiver programs, also known as property damage liability waiver programs,and renters insurance policies are often obtained at the same time as lease agreements, and both serve to protect the property owner and renter from financial costs related to tenant-caused property damage. But the two types of protection differ, so it’s important to understand the difference between tenant legal liability waiver programs and renters insurance to ensure you are protected.  

What Is a TLL Waiver?

A Tenant Legal Liability Waiver is a legally binding agreement between a landlord and a resident in which the landlord waives the tenant’s liability to the landlord for the damage the resident negligently caused to the landlord’s property.  A Waiver is not insurance for the resident.  But, when the resident enrolls in the Waiver program, the landlord waives the resident’s lease obligation to purchase renters insurance. While the primary goal of a Waiver is to protect the owner from having to pay to repair property damage caused by an insured resident, it also allows residents to meet their lease obligations, and protects them from the legal and financial obligations to their landlord when they negligently cause property damage losses resulting from:

  • Fire
  • Smoke  
  • Explosion
  • Leaks and other water overflows

Waiver programs are backed by specialized commercial insurance policies that are issued to the landlords to cover the expenses from the damage caused by enrolled residents. Some Landlords opt to include a supplemental benefit in their Waiver programs for limited reimbursement of damage to residents’ personal property as well as living expenses.

Waiver fees are typically wrapped into rent payments and can range from $10 to $25 per month. Depending on the owner’s Waiver program, residents can be automatically enrolled at the time of lease signing unless they opt-out by supplying proof of their own renters insurance policy that meets the lease’s compliance requirements. That brings us to our next point.  

What Is Renters Insurance (HO4 Insurance)?

Renters insurance, on the other hand, is an insurance policy purchased by the resident and the resident is the named insured. Renters insurance policies typically cover the same property damage losses as TLL waivers, in that the policies provide liability coverage for residents.  If a resident negligently causes damage to the landlord’s property or the property of neighboring residents, the renters insurance carrier will compensate the landlord and the other residents for the damage their insured caused. Also, residents typically have the option to purchase personal contents coverage for their renters insurance policy, which will cover the cost of replacing their belongings if they are stolen or become damaged due to negligence or a natural disaster. The policy can also protect residents from liability if someone is injured on their property. If selected as a coverage, renters insurance will also cover living expenses if a resident needs to relocate while their primary residence is being repaired due to damage caused by a covered event.  

Because it typically includes more coverages and has policy limits for the individual renter, renters insurance tends to be slightly more expensive than TLL waiver programs, coming in at $15 to $25 per month on average. Unlike TLL waiver programs, renters may be asked to source their own renter’s insurance, which they can get from most insurance providers.  

Key Differences Between TLL Waivers and Renters Insurance  

The primary differences between a Waiver and renters insurance is that a Waiver is a contractual release of liability between the landlord and resident (with only the landlord obtaining an insurance policy), while renters insurance is insurance purchased by the resident, who is the named insured. Also, while a Waiver is an excellent option to safeguard both parties from the financial costs caused to the landlord’s property from the most common types of resident-caused property damage, renters insurance offers the renter broad coverage for their belongings and coverage for their liability to parties other than the landlord. While beneficial to both parties, the main purpose of a tenant legal liability waiver is to protect property owners from damage caused by resident negligence. Renters insurance, on the other hand, provides more protections for the renter.  

Though renters insurance tends to be more expensive than TLL waiver programs and may require a separate monthly payment to a third party, it also offers greater protection and more customization than a standard TLL waiver program.  

While state and federal laws don’t require renters insurance or TLL waiver programs, landlords have the option of making them a requirement for all residents through their lease agreement.  

When Should Renters Choose to Enroll in a TLL Waiver?

TLL waivers provide an affordable alternative to liability (renters) insurance for renters preparing to sign a new lease. They are most beneficial for residents who live in areas with low crime rates and minimal risk of natural disasters. Residents who want to protect themselves from liability in the case of an accident damaging their landlord’s property but aren’t storing valuable items in their rented unit are perfect candidates for TLL waivers. Though limited in their scope, TLL waivers are a low-cost, mutually beneficial option for tenants and property owners. Ultimately, it’s up to the renter to determine the option that suits them best.

When Should Renters Choose Renters Insurance?

Renters insurance is ideal for residents who are looking for more protection than a TLL Waiver can provide. If residents want to protect valuable assets in their unit from damage or theft, or if they live in a neighborhood with a high risk of crime or natural disasters, renter’s insurance may be a better solution. Because renters insurance also covers costs associated with injuries sustained on a person’s property, it’s a wise option for those who can afford to expand their coverage to ensure they are protected against unexpected legal expenses.    

Coverage That Meets Your Residents’ Needs and Budget  

TLL waivers and renters insurance are both great options for renters. Renters should assess their needs and finances to determine which option is best for their unique needs.  

Foxen makes securing coverage easy, whether you’re looking to implement a TLL waiver program or offer your residents a convenient option to purchase renters insurance. We help you implement a renters insurance compliance monitoring program in 45 days or less that meets your property needs, automatically enrolling renters in our TLL waiver program or giving them the ability to easily purchase renters insurance coverage from our partner MSI™ at the time of lease signing. If your residents’ third-party insurance policy ends at any point during the lease term, we’ll automatically enroll them in the TLL waiver program to ensure they are compliant and your property is adequately protected.  

Get Started with Foxen

If you’re looking to protect your property, learn more by requesting a demo today.